Tensions flare as judge declines to remove | Quik

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.This video can not be played

Watch: What it was like in court as Lindsay Clancy's lawyer asked judge to remove juror

A judge has again told the deadlocked jury in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial to keep trying to reach a verdict after a dramatic sixth day of deliberations in a case that has gripped America.

Tensions flared in court after the jury forewoman sent the judge a note saying one juror would not follow the judge's instructions on reasonable doubt.

There was audible shock in the room when the defence team asked for the juror to be removed, a request that was denied by the judge.

Clancy, 36, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of her three children - Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan - at her Massachusetts family home on 24 January 2023.

Warning: This article contains distressing details

The former labour and delivery nurse does not deny strangling her two sons and daughter in the basement of their house.

But her lawyer argues she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time, and could not distinguish right from wrong.

The jury of nine women and three men in Plymouth has deliberated for some 35 hours without a verdict, following nearly six weeks of trial proceedings.

The panel has twice previously sent the judge notes saying it could not come to a unanimous decision, but Thursday was the first hint of rancour in the deliberation room.

Could Lindsay Clancy trial end in a mistrial? Here are the jury's options

Published5 hours agoTo play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.This video can not be played

Watch: Moment Clancy's defence urges judge to dismiss juror

Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, said in court that the jury forewoman had sent another note, this one complaining to Judge William Sullivan that a juror was refusing to listen to the law on reasonable doubt.

Reddington and prosecutor Jennifer Sprague had an animated discussion with the judge in court.

Reddington then went over to Clancy to explain what had just happened, in what seemed to be a tense conversation.

Clancy, who was paralysed from the waist down when she jumped out of a second-floor window after killing her children, was pushed in her wheelchair by her lawyer to join a discussion with the judge.

Afterwards, Judge Sullivan brought in each juror individually and questioned them.

He reminded the panel they must unanimously believe beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty in order to convict her of a crime. As each juror came up, some looked at Clancy, while others did not.

When the defence lawyer told the court about his request to have a juror removed, there were gasps and reporters quickly began typing.

"I don't feel it is proper for me to side with one side or the other of the deliberations," the judge said.

Sprague, the prosecutor, said the judge's instructions to the jurors were appropriate.

"There's no way to determine what the deliberations are, who's correct, who's incorrect, nor should we attempt to," she said.

Reddington, looking upset, could be seen consoling his client, holding her in a side hug and rubbing her back as journalists left court.

The defence lawyer told reporters afterwards that the forewoman's note to the judge stated that there was one holdout in the jury who, as he described it, "refuses to listen to the law... on reasonable doubt".

Reddington said he had suggested to the judge "a motion to remove the juror who refuses to accept your instructions on the law on a reasonable doubt".

The defence lawyer said he had no indication of what this lone juror was thinking and he did not confirm the 11-1 split the jury forewoman reported earlier.

The issue with the juror is expected to be addressed again when court convenes at 09:00 EST (14:00 BST) on Friday.

If the jury does not reach a verdict and Judge Sullivan declares a mistrial, prosecutors would need to decide whether to retry the case.

Clancy faces life in prison without parole if convicted of first-degree murder.

If found not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, or reason of insanity, she could be committed to a state psychiatric hospital.

Under US law, a jury must unanimously believe "beyond a reasonable doubt" that someone is guilty in order to convict them of a crime.

The designation is the strictest standard in the US legal system. It places the burden on the government to prove that the accused is guilty, and not the accused to prove their innocence.

If you are suffering distress or despair and need support, you could speak to a health professional, or an organisation that offers support. Details of help available in many countries can be found at Befrienders Worldwide. www.befrienders.org.

In the UK a list of organisations that can help is available at bbc.co.uk/actionline.

Woman charged with juror intimidation in Lindsay Clancy trial

Key moments in trial of Lindsay Clancy, the mother accused of murdering her three children

PreviousNext1:34Feminist activist Gloria Steinem on her legacy. 00:01:34, play videoFeminist activist Gloria Steinem on her legacy1:20'The greatest privilege' - dad donates organs to son. 00:01:20, play video'The greatest privilege' - dad donates organs to son0:41Why are there three hurricanes in the Pacific? 00:00:41, play videoWhy are there three hurricanes in the Pacific?0:59Will El Nino bring chaos to UK weather? 00:00:59, play videoWill El Nino bring chaos to UK weather?0:49Amelia Dimoldenberg to close doors of Chicken Shop Date. 00:00:49, play videoAmelia Dimoldenberg to close doors of Chicken Shop Date1:28Social media 'spiral' found after sister's death. 00:01:28, play videoSocial media 'spiral' found after sister's death1:14'I was struck by lightning and survived' 00:01:14, play video'I was struck by lightning and survived'1:00How much should you give towards a leaving gift? 00:01:00, play videoHow much should you give towards a leaving gift?1:32Were Christians the target of the Palm Sunday attack in Nigeria? 00:01:32, play videoWere Christians the target of the Palm Sunday attack in Nigeria?0:48Trump: Harry and Meghan treated Royal Family with 'great disrespect' 00:00:48, play videoTrump: Harry and Meghan treated Royal Family with 'great disrespect'1:05Fake Downing Street listing on Booking.com. 00:01:05, play videoFake Downing Street listing on Booking.com1:05'My auntie cooked for Churchill during WWII' 00:01:05, play video'My auntie cooked for Churchill during WWII'1:03What can fans expect from series 2 of The Gentleman? 00:01:03, play videoWhat can fans expect from series 2 of The Gentleman?0:46King says Bayeux Tapestry shows the 'French side of my family' 00:00:46, play videoKing says Bayeux Tapestry shows the 'French side of my family'0:36Moment Tyler Robinson pleads not guilty to Charlie Kirk's murder. 00:00:36, play videoMoment Tyler Robinson pleads not guilty to Charlie Kirk's murder1:16Why US troops have a history in this raucous Thai city. 00:01:16, play videoWhy US troops have a history in this raucous Thai cityTop storiesFarage senior aide filmed suggesting way to avoid donations law

Live. Two people rescued from Nepal tunnel more than a week after flash flood

Controversial Jackdaw gas field set to be approved in weeks, sources say

Girl group Katseye are missing two members, but their tour still dazzles

From cake to pizza: How to get the best birthday freebies (and why there's a catch)

AI data centres are booming in Australia - but at what cost?

Weekly quiz: What has been named TikTok's song of the summer in the UK?

The Papers: 'Foreign donations sting' and 'Argentina threat to Falklands'

'Gromit was nearly a cat!': Secrets from 50 years of Aardman

How Gloria Steinem changed the lives of generations of women

Canada unveils new $20 bill featuring portrait of King Charles

US Politics Unspun: Cut through the noise with Anthony Zurcher's newsletter

Relive all the electrifying performances of Reading Festival

Meet Jim Swearingen, the creator of the Star Wars toys

Greg Jenner and guests examine the tumultuous events of 1066

What are the impacts of toxic masculinity on women?

Farage senior aide filmed suggesting way to avoid donations law

Argentine leader says oil firms working off Falklands face sanctions

'Foreign donations sting' and 'Argentina threat to Falklands'

Girl group Katseye are missing two members, but their tour still dazzles

'I lost my savings after a job interview scam'

Controversial Jackdaw gas field set to be approved in weeks, sources say

Volkswagen board approves plan to cut another 50,000 jobs

Transplanted pig kidney works in US man's body for record 271 days

'Miracle' eagle with broken wing spotted back above Scottish coast

British army told to stop non-essential training exercises to save money