Naqvi comes to CDA chairman, Islamabad IG's defence as carriage video draws flak

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi on Saturday came to the defence of two government officials who drew flak after a video of them riding in a horse carriage during an Independence Day parade in Islamabad went viral on social media. In the widely circulated video, two officials, identified as Capital Development Authority (CDA) Chairman retired Lt Sohail Ashraf and the Islamabad Inspector General of Police (IGP) Syed Ali Nasir Rizvi, are seen riding into a parade in a horse carriage. Even as the attendees are prompted to applaud for the officials, no claps are heard in the video. The video sparked criticism on social media, with many likening the act to a “colonial” mindset. Meanwhile, Naqvi issued a clarification on X, stating that it was not the officials’ fault. “The chief guest and I were delayed due to the president’s meeting with the prime minister. The crowd had been waiting since 5pm, and at around 6:00 pm, when it became clear that we would be late, we instructed the officers to start the programme because we did not want the public to wait any longer.” Naqvi maintained that the carriage was arranged for the chief guest but had to be used by officers “due to unavoidable circumstances”. “I can say on record that both officers initially resisted starting the programme in our absence, but we specifically instructed them to proceed for the convenience of the public,” he said, adding that he remained grateful to the residents of Islamabad for making the event “a true celebration”.

But others continued with the criticism. Even after his clarification, former federal minister Shireen Mazari shared a post by digital rights activist Usama Khilji that included the video and said, “Unbelievably stupid to try and revive such colonial practices! Self-humiliation!”

Khilji, in his post, criticised the two officials, saying, “This is what happens when you do things unbecoming of your office”. He added, “Pakistan’s political class has its problems, but at the end of the day they have to pander to citizens for support, votes and legitimacy; however flawed. Civil and military bureaucracy, on the other hand, functions with complete impunity, much like the British Raj from which we inherited them.”

Journalist Farzana Ali, reacting to the video, questioned: “Are these scenes from the same country where a new burden is imposed on poverty-stricken people every day on the pretext that the country is facing difficulties?”

Journalist Zarrar Khuhro also shared the video with a one-word caption: “CRINGE”.

Researcher Ammar Rashid stressed that the “pindrop silence” from the audience at the carriage’s arrival indicated the “contempt” the public had for “these unelected babus ruining our cities”. “Anti-people DC Raj needs to go,” he wrote on X.

Journalist and former chairman of the Pakistan Electronic Media Authority (Pemra) Absar Alam also reacted to the video, saying it was “revolting” to look at the “inferiority complex of brown sahibs of bureaucracy”.