Meta hooked children on Facebook and Instagram, court hears

A jury in Oakland, California will spend the next six weeks wading through claims by top attorneys from several US states, and lawyers for the social media company, that at turns rebutted the other as the trial opened.

Meta's representative said just over 100,000 such users were found, and also argued that social media addiction does not exist.

After the state lawyer said Meta knew its platforms hurt teen mental health, Meta's side said it was being ignored how many more teens had good experiences

The trial stems from a lawsuit filed in 2023 by 29 US states, including California and New York, in which they claim numerous violations of federal and state privacy laws for children.

The trial started off on Tuesday with a battle of words and facts.

Paul Schmidt, a lead attorney for Meta in the trial, directly addressed an internal research report that Megan O'Neill, a lead attorney for California, made part of the states' opening arguments.

Schmidt said: "That sounds pretty bad."

"What else does the document say?" Schmidt went on. "That 41% of teens said it made them feel better and another 41% said it had no effect."

As for Meta being able to verify the age of every user on its platform, Schmidt argued that the very privacy laws Meta was being accused of violating in the case prevent it from saving and using the data it would need to effectively track underage users.

When it comes to addiction, Schmidt argued a point that Meta has put forward in at other litigation this year: that social media addiction does not exist.

"There can be no dispute that Meta has recognised people struggle, or can struggle, with their use of social media, and has come up with tools to try and address that," Schmidt said.

O'Neill's opening arguments seemed to challenge Schmidt's argument.

She relied heavily on information found in millions of documents provided in the case from Meta, including internal research, employee emails, and chat logs, all the way up Zuckerberg.

In another that O'Neill pointed the jury to, Meta found "product features designed to increase time spent are inherently at odds with well-being and take away from people's ability to focus on activity that adds value to their lives".

Meta's business model could be summed up this way: "Hook the users; hold them for as long as they can; harvest their data; hide the truth from the public when making public statements," she said.

She said that throughout the trial, it would become clear that what Meta said publicly about its platforms, and what its internal research showed, were very different.

"Meta said it put safety over profits, but hid the reality that, time and again, when it came to make a decision, profits won."

PreviousNext0:34‘It was taking over their lives’: Young people on Meta trial. 00:00:34, play video‘It was taking over their lives’: Young people on Meta trial0:41British newlyweds killed in Greek helicopter crash named. 00:00:41, play videoBritish newlyweds killed in Greek helicopter crash named0:59Warehouse full of seized life jackets from small boats gangs. 00:00:59, play videoWarehouse full of seized life jackets from small boats gangs0:27'A real hero' - Trump meets teen lifeguard after rescue. 00:00:27, play video'A real hero' - Trump meets teen lifeguard after rescue0:39Disabled people in England to get 24-hour free bus travel. 00:00:39, play videoDisabled people in England to get 24-hour free bus travel1:02Doctors remove record-size bladder stone. 00:01:02, play videoDoctors remove record-size bladder stone0:41Wetherspoons bans customers playing music from phones. 00:00:41, play videoWetherspoons bans customers playing music from phones0:25Trump on Burnham being duped by White House imposter. 00:00:25, play videoTrump on Burnham being duped by White House imposter1:53Tupac murder trial hears: 'All hell broke loose' 00:01:53, play videoTupac murder trial hears: 'All hell broke loose'0:43Has the hot weather of summer 2026 finally passed? 00:00:43, play videoHas the hot weather of summer 2026 finally passed?1:27Could Reform really cut £50bn in welfare? 00:01:27, play videoCould Reform really cut £50bn in welfare?1:45Why has Trump shifted on North Korea? 00:01:45, play videoWhy has Trump shifted on North Korea?1:00Hayden Panettiere's iconic video game characters. 00:01:00, play videoHayden Panettiere's iconic video game characters0:43Why Haaland is a better FPL pick than ever. 00:00:43, play videoWhy Haaland is a better FPL pick than ever1:24Why are men getting penis fillers? 00:01:24, play videoWhy are men getting penis fillers?0:54Thousands attend vigil following Jason Arday's death. 00:00:54, play videoThousands attend vigil following Jason Arday's death2:00Parents caught up in Cyprus IVF sperm scandal. 00:02:00, play videoParents caught up in Cyprus IVF sperm scandal0:41One pan harissa chicken with chickpeas. 00:00:41, play videoOne pan harissa chicken with chickpeas0:54PM messaged with person posing as Trump official. 00:00:54, play videoPM messaged with person posing as Trump official0:42What Hayden Panettiere's book told us about her life. 00:00:42, play videoWhat Hayden Panettiere's book told us about her lifeTop storiesThree dead after family get into difficulty in sea

'Everyone in for Christmas' - Burnham unveils rough sleeping plan

Scientists stunned by children's lung recovery in ultra low emission zone

'Banned over a pair of £2 sandals': Why some sellers are complaining about Vinted

Tracking USS Lincoln's months-long mission as concerns about conditions grow. VideoTracking USS Lincoln's months-long mission as concerns about conditions grow

Is another UK heatwave on the way in September?

'I'm in Barbados': The dos and don'ts of writing an out-of-office reply

Erin survived cancer aged 21 - now it's a race against time for a chance of a baby

The Papers: 'Look at my husband' and 'Vlad plots revenge'

National Television Awards pick first all-female shortlist for drama acting award

How one man gets new laws passed - again and again

News Daily: Our flagship daily newsletter delivered to your inbox first thing, with all the latest headlines

Puzzle over the cryptic comedy drama before it returns

Meet two incredible women who work on saving the world's plants

Michael Sheen uncovers alleged toxic contamination in Wales

Two people are found dead in an apparent suicide pact, until a killer confesses

Three dead after family get into difficulty in sea

Scientists stunned by children's lung recovery in ultra low emission zone

Burnham received £345,000 of donations ahead of becoming PM

'Look at my husband' and 'Vlad plots revenge'

One dead and hundreds ill in UK salmonella outbreak

'Everyone in for Christmas' - Burnham unveils rough sleeping plan

Camilla admits it was 'difficult' to keep King's cancer diagnosis a secret

The 'fiddly and frustrating' work removing 10,000 coins from Giant's Causeway columns

Harvard agrees to pay millions after morgue manager sold body parts