Lindsay Clancy holdout juror had no doubt she deliberately killed her children

Image source, ReutersByJessica RawnsleyPublished41 minutes agoThe lone holdout juror in the trial of Lindsay Clancy has said he "didn't have any doubts" that she was criminally responsible for killing her three children.

"Based on all the physical evidence, key witnesses and what the prosecution presents, I thought it was enough proof that she knew exactly what she was doing and planned it," Michael Desronvil said in a statement to CBS News, the BBC's US partner.

The judge declared a mistrial on 4 September after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict following nearly 40 hours of deliberating.

Clancy admitted to the killings but her lawyers argued she had been suffering from postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors said the killings were calculated.

Warning: This article contains distressing details

The 36-year-old was charged with three counts of first-degree murder after strangling Cora, five, Dawson, three, and Callan, eight months, at the family's Massachusetts home before jumping out of the second-floor window.

To find Clancy guilty, jurors had to be unanimously convinced beyond reasonable doubt that she intentionally killed her children and that she did not do so as a result of postpartum psychosis, a rare and serious condition.

The jury - nine women and three men - considered a range of options including not guilty by reason of insanity, manslaughter and first-degree murder.

Several jurors have said following the mistrial being declared that the panel was ultimately divided 11-1 in favour of finding Clancy not criminally responsible.

Desronvil said he believed the evidence presented in court showed she had planned the killings.

"I didn't have any doubts," he said in a statement to CBS on Thursday.

"As I tried to explain different possible theories during deliberation, I kept getting cut off as if I had doubts based on the evidence presented."

'Emotional rollercoaster' - Lindsay Clancy jurors speak out on what led to mistrial

Published9 SeptemberWhat happens next after Lindsay Clancy's murder case ends in a mistrial?

Published5 SeptemberPaula Devlin, one of the other jurors, told CBS Mornings that the panel had spent several days trying to convince Desronvil to change his mind.

"We all worked together to convince ourselves once we got to that point where it was 10 to 2," she said.

The jury foreperson, a retired fifth-grade teacher, described not being able to reach a verdict as "awful" and an "emotional rollercoaster".

She told NBC that Desronvil had "admitted he had reasonable doubt", but as she started filling out the verdict sheets, he apparently said: "But I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity."

Another juror told local CBS station WBZ-TV that most of the jurors had been "very firm in their stance" from the start and "the stand-alone juror was not the only one that was unwilling to see things from the other side".

But they added that because Desronvil would not "follow" his reasonable doubt nor offer logical reasoning for his position, they felt Clancy had not received a fair trial.

The identities of all 11 jurors have not been officially disclosed but in the US, once a case is over, any juror can choose to speak publicly about a case and their deliberations.

Patrick Clancy, the children's father and Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband, is due to speak publicly about the case in an interview with the CBS programme 60 Minutes on Sunday.

In it, he is expected to discuss his grief, his memories of his children and the conspiracy theories that have flooded social media since the trial began.

He said he still speaks to his children "all the time", describing it as "a way I stay connected to them".

During the trial, Clancy's defence team had attempted to use her being put on more than a dozen medications in the lead-up to the killings, as well as seeking help from a suicide hotline and an emergency room, as evidence of her psychosis.

Postpartum psychosis can involve hallucinations and delusions, and her lawyers argued that she was unable to understand the nature of her actions or distinguish right from wrong.

A forensic psychiatrist who testified for the defence said Clancy experienced a "command hallucination" and a "delusion of influence" when she killed her children.

However, her psychiatrist testified for the prosecution that Clancy did not show signs of psychosis during their sessions, while another psychiatrist noted that the condition was not currently recognised by the American Psychiatric Association.

Under Massachusetts law, prosecutors had to prove beyond any reasonable doubt that Clancy was criminally responsible for the jury to find her guilty. The defence did not have to prove her mental illness or lack of criminal responsibility.

The mistrial leaves the case unresolved. Prosecutors have not said whether they will seek a retrial.

Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, has said he hopes to reach an agreement with prosecutors to avoid a second trial.

He told ABC's Good Morning America that he was upset that the lone juror would not acquit Clancy.

He said the holdout "would not apply the law of reasonable doubt" as instructed by the judge, adding: "That's not right. And that's why I was upset."

The next court hearing is scheduled for 29 September at Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts.

Lindsay Clancy murder trial has divided US on whether she's victim or criminal

US mother's mental health spiralled before her children's murders, ex-husband says

Key moments from Lindsay Clancy's trial over children's killings

The video playlistWatch our pick of standout clips from across the BBC

PreviousNext1:29Is democracy for sale? 00:01:29, play videoIs democracy for sale?1:29Could YouTube replace driving instructors? 00:01:29, play videoCould YouTube replace driving instructors?1:06'I would tip up to 30% at a restaurant' 00:01:06, play video'I would tip up to 30% at a restaurant'0:54Can humpback whales experience grief? 00:00:54, play videoCan humpback whales experience grief?0:50How El Niño could bring winter snow to the UK. 00:00:50, play videoHow El Niño could bring winter snow to the UK1:19Are till receipts messing with our hormones? 00:01:19, play videoAre till receipts messing with our hormones?1:01Beverley Knight's Proms tribute to Dolly Parton. 00:01:01, play videoBeverley Knight's Proms tribute to Dolly Parton1:08Royal row intensifies after fresh claims in Diana's brother book. 00:01:08, play videoRoyal row intensifies after fresh claims in Diana's brother book1:24Ed Sheeran's tour in 'damage control mode' 00:01:24, play videoEd Sheeran's tour in 'damage control mode'1:03Family blame Met for suicide of suspect in 'Putney Pusher' case. 00:01:03, play videoFamily blame Met for suicide of suspect in 'Putney Pusher' case0:56Nato chief: 'Let's not be naive about what Putin could do' 00:00:56, play videoNato chief: 'Let's not be naive about what Putin could do'0:37Why is the Canadian PM an Everton fan? 00:00:37, play videoWhy is the Canadian PM an Everton fan?0:45Inside the 'scariest house on Rightmove' 00:00:45, play videoInside the 'scariest house on Rightmove'0:56Who is Earl Spencer, the man making claims against King Charles? 00:00:56, play videoWho is Earl Spencer, the man making claims against King Charles?1:04'I went missing for six years, now I've got a job' 00:01:04, play video'I went missing for six years, now I've got a job'0:59You'll have to pay for Mount Fuji off-season helicopter rescues. 00:00:59, play videoYou'll have to pay for Mount Fuji off-season helicopter rescues1:04River with 500 crocodiles chosen as Olympic rowing venue. 00:01:04, play videoRiver with 500 crocodiles chosen as Olympic rowing venue0:21Snapchat 'willing to implement' time limits for teens, boss tells BBC. 00:00:21, play videoSnapchat 'willing to implement' time limits for teens, boss tells BBC1:13Why caffeine makes some people buzz. 00:01:13, play videoWhy caffeine makes some people buzzTop storiesMI5 accepts it gave evidence based on lies in neo-Nazi spy case

Twenty women had breasts removed needlessly, says NHS trust

Sisters of 'Putney pusher' suspect say DNA will clear his name

Woman tells BBC of trauma after unnecessary breast cancer surgery. VideoWoman tells BBC of trauma after unnecessary breast cancer surgery

We bought our £242,000 home without a deposit - here's how

Watch: Can humpback whales experience grief? VideoWatch: Can humpback whales experience grief?

Harry Styles funds free coffee at two London cafes

Weekly quiz: Why did women's sports stars criticise actress Sydney Sweeney?

Tailgate parties, marching bands... and Ted Lasso? Wembley hosts US college game

Fenced-in woman, 81, wins three-year access fight

'Complete despair': Afghan female medical students fear being sent home from Pakistan

Tech Decoded newsletter: Follow the world’s top tech stories and trends

Watch every gripping episode of This City Is Ours before it returns

How do electric fish make electricity?

Puzzle lovers: All episodes of Ludwig are available now on iPlayer

Brewdog's unpaid workers to receive nothing after takeover deal

Council staff refused anonymity for Sara Sharif inquest

Sisters of 'Putney pusher' suspect say DNA will clear his name

Lindsay Clancy holdout juror had no doubt she deliberately killed her children

Twenty women had breasts removed needlessly, says NHS trust

War may be coming. Are we psychologically ready?

MI5 accepts it gave evidence based on lies in neo-Nazi spy case

Oasis will not headline Glastonbury 2027, organiser Emily Eavis confirms

We bought our £242,000 home without a deposit - here's how